Fault disputes

Insurer says it was your fault? That's not the final word.

Their decision is their view, not a court ruling, and evidence can change it. Check your claim in about 60 seconds. It's free, with no obligation.

Free claim check · Question 1

What kind of accident were you in?

Takes about 60 seconds. Free, with no obligation.

No upfront attorney's fees. We never send your details to lots of firms. Attorney advertising. We're not a law firm.

The insurer says it was your fault. Now what?

The short answer

An insurance company's decision on fault isn't final. Ask for the denial in writing with the reasons, gather your evidence and respond. In Arizona you can usually still recover even if you share some of the blame, and in Georgia you can as long as you were less than 50% at fault. An attorney can challenge the decision and, if needed, file a lawsuit before the deadline.

Their decision isn't the last word

The adjuster decides fault for the insurer's purposes. It's their view, not a court ruling. If a claim goes to court, a judge or jury decides fault based on the evidence.

Get it in writing

Ask for the decision in writing, with the reasons and the evidence they relied on. You can't challenge a decision you haven't seen.

The 3-Point Claim Check

  1. 1

    An injury

    You were hurt, even if it didn't seem serious at first.

  2. 2

    Someone else at fault

    Another driver or company caused the crash.

  3. 3

    Insurance coverage

    There's a policy that may cover what happened.

Evidence that can change the picture

  • The police report, and whether anyone was cited.
  • Photos of the vehicles, the damage and the scene.
  • Witness names and statements.
  • Dashcam, doorbell or business camera video. Ask quickly, since it's often deleted.
  • Phone records or vehicle data, which an attorney can request.

Shared fault doesn't always end your claim

In Arizona, you can usually still recover if you share some of the blame, with the amount reduced by your share (A.R.S. § 12-2505).

In Georgia, you can recover if you were less than 50% at fault, again reduced by your share (O.C.G.A. § 51-12-33).

Your own coverage may still help

Your own policy may include medical payments, collision or uninsured motorist coverage. Ask your insurer what applies.

How it works

  1. 1

    Answer a few questions

    Tell us what happened. It takes about a minute.

  2. 2

    A local attorney's office calls you

    If it looks like you might have a claim, we match you with one participating attorney near you, and their office gives you a quick call.

  3. 3

    They explain your options for free

    No upfront attorney's fees, and they're only paid if you recover.

Common questions

Can I appeal the insurer's decision?

There's no formal appeal like in court, but you can ask them to reconsider with new evidence. If that doesn't work, an attorney can negotiate or file a lawsuit.

Does the police report decide fault?

It's important evidence, but it isn't the final word. Insurers and courts look at all the evidence.

Should I claim on my own insurance instead?

You may be able to use your own coverage while the fault dispute is sorted out. Check your policy and ask an attorney how it affects your claim.

Related guides

Last reviewed October 2026. This is general information, not legal advice. Every case is different.

Find out where you stand.It takes about 60 seconds.

Start free check

Answer a few quick questions. If it looks like you may have a claim, a local injury attorney's office will give you a call soon, so keep your phone close. You don't have to go ahead.